Your CPMs Are Up 40%. Is That You or Is That November?
Table of content:
Your CPMs are up 44% on last November. Someone in a group chat says theirs are down 15%. A third brand is 20% cheaper than last month and 50% more expensive than last year. None of you can tell whether that means anything.
This is the most common anxiety of the fortnight, and the honest answer is that a CPM number on its own tells you almost nothing. This post covers the comparisons that do tell you something, what our own portfolio curve looks like, and when a rise is genuinely your problem.
Why does a CPM number tell you so little?
Because it is a price, and prices move for reasons that have nothing to do with you.
Your CPM reflects who else is bidding for the same people at the same moment. In November that set changes daily as every advertiser in your category raises budget. A 40% rise can mean your creative weakened, your audience narrowed, your competitors got richer, or your category simply became popular. The number cannot distinguish between those.
Worse, CPM can fall while you get poorer. Delivery drifting toward cheaper placements or less valuable audiences lowers the price and lowers the quality with it. A falling CPM is not automatically good news.
What does a normal November curve look like?
Rising from a mid October floor, steeply through the peak weekend, and continuing to rise into mid December.
Across the Webtopia portfolio in Q4 2025, covering 19 Meta ad accounts and roughly $10.2 million of spend, CPMs ran a low of $8.33 in mid October and peaked at $15.55 on 8 December. That is roughly a doubling across eight weeks, with about 50% of the rise landing between the October floor and the Cyber 5 window.
Use that shape rather than the absolute numbers. Your own CPM depends on your category, your country and your targeting, so what travels between brands is the direction and the rough gradient, not the price.
How should you compare year on year?
On the same days relative to Black Friday, not the same calendar dates.
Black Friday moves. Comparing 16 November 2026 with 16 November 2025 compares a day that is eleven days out with a day that was eleven days out, which happens to work this year, but the same comparison in other years lines up entirely different phases of the run up. Align on days before Black Friday and the comparison becomes meaningful.
Then hold the other variables still. A year on year CPM comparison means nothing if your targeting, placements, objective or country mix changed in between, and for most brands at least one of those did.
What does a CPM rise with a steady conversion rate mean?
It usually means the market got more expensive and your offer still works. That is the good version of this problem.
The combination to watch is CPM, click through rate and conversion rate together. CPM up with click through rate and conversion rate holding is a price change you are absorbing. CPM up with click through rate falling points at saturation, which is covered in why Black Friday ads stop working in week two. CPM up with conversion rate falling points at the offer or the landing page rather than the media.
Cost per acquisition is the number that resolves it. In our portfolio, Cyber 5 cost per acquisition held broadly level with late September despite CPMs rising around 50% from the October low, because intent rose fast enough to absorb the inflation. Expensive and efficient can be true at the same time.
When is a CPM rise actually your problem?
Four signals, and each points somewhere specific.
Frequency climbing alongside CPM means your audience is too small for your budget. CPM rising only in some campaigns means a targeting or creative issue rather than a market one. A rise that started before the end of October predates the seasonal effect. And CPM rising while impressions fall at a steady budget means delivery is struggling, which usually traces back to a learning reset or a policy flag.
Anything else is probably the auction, and the auction is not a problem you can fix. It is a cost you plan around.
What should you do about it this week?
Judge the spend against your acquisition ceiling rather than against last year's CPM.
The question that matters is whether a customer still costs less than you can afford to pay, which is a margin calculation rather than a media one. If the answer is yes, a higher CPM is the price of the season. If the answer is no, that is a signal to pull back regardless of how normal the rise looks. The derivation is in maximum CAC, and the buying tactics for an expensive auction are in Q4 CPM inflation.
What to record before Thursday
Your own baseline, so that December has something honest to compare against.
Write down this week's CPM, click through rate, conversion rate, new customer acquisition cost and blended acquisition cost, with the date and your current targeting setup beside them. It takes ten minutes and it is the difference between a January post mortem that explains what happened and one that argues about it.
The full metric set is in the Q4 profit scorecard, and the portfolio cost curves sit in the Q4 Profit Playbook, free and written for founder led DTC brands on Shopify at $5M to $30M. Webtopia runs peak media for founder led brands as an ecommerce paid media agency.
Frequently asked questions
Are high CPMs normal in November?
Rising CPMs are normal. Across our portfolio they ran from a mid October low of $8.33 to a peak of $15.55 on 8 December, with about half the rise landing before the Cyber 5 window.
How much do CPMs rise before Black Friday?
In our accounts, roughly 50% from the mid October floor into the peak weekend. Your own figure depends on category, country and targeting, so use the shape rather than the number.
Should I compare CPMs to the same date last year?
Compare the same number of days before Black Friday instead, since the date moves. Also check that targeting, placements, objective and country mix have not changed in between.
My CPM is up but conversion rate is steady. Is that a problem?
Usually not. That combination means the market got more expensive while your offer still works. Judge it on cost per acquisition against what you can afford to pay.
Is a falling CPM good news?
Not always. Delivery drifting to cheaper placements or less valuable audiences lowers the price and the quality together, so check conversion rate alongside it.
Get weekly expert insights!
Built from scaling real brands
Turn your ad spend into real growth.
At Webtopia, we don’t just run ads. We build scalable growth systems designed for ambitious DTC brands. By combining performance marketing, creative strategy, and data-backed execution, we help founders scale without sacrificing profitability. Our clients see an average 6X blended ROAS every month, because great brands deserve more than short-term wins.
Book your call today and let’s build your next growth chapter together.